Delhi HC clarifies restaurants have no interim relief to levy mandatory service charges | India News

delhi hc


Delhi HC clarifies restaurants have no interim relief to levy mandatory service charges

NEW DELHI: Delhi high court on Thursday clarified that it has not granted any interim relief to restaurants allowing them to continue charging mandatory service charges from customers, despite an earlier judgment declaring the practice illegal.A Division Bench of Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma said no interim protection had been granted to restaurant associations against the March 28, 2025, judgment of a single judge, which upheld the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) guidelines prohibiting compulsory service charges.The clarification came after Additional Solicitor General Chetan Sharma, appearing for the government told the court that some restaurants were still making service charges mandatory for customers, contrary to the High Court’s earlier ruling, ANI reported.Sharma submitted that restaurants could not continue the practice after the single judge had upheld the CCPA guidelines prohibiting hotels and restaurants from automatically adding service charges to food bills.Responding to the submission, the bench said it had not granted any interim relief to the restaurant associations in their appeals.“Where is the interim relief? Where is the interim relief in their favour? We have not granted any interim prayer,” Acting Chief Justice Sambre remarked.The court was hearing appeals filed by the National Restaurant Association of India (NRAI) and the Federation of Hotel and Restaurant Associations of India (FHRAI) against the single judge’s March 2025 judgment.What the 2025 judgment saidOn March 28, 2025, Justice Prathiba M Singh dismissed petitions filed by NRAI and FHRAI challenging the CCPA guidelines issued on July 4, 2022.The single judge ruled that restaurants cannot make service charges compulsory, even if they are mentioned on menus. Customers cannot be forced to pay such charges, which must remain voluntary.The court held that collecting service charges without a customer’s consent amounts to an unfair trade practice under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. It also upheld the CCPA’s authority to issue guidelines to protect consumer rights and prevent unfair trade practices, imposing costs of Rs 1 lakh on the restaurant associations.The judgment further said restaurants cannot automatically add service charges to bills. Customers must be informed that any additional payment towards service or staff welfare is voluntary.The single judge had also expressed concern over the use of the term ‘service charge’, observing that it could mislead customers into believing it was a government-imposed tax.Why restaurant associations challenged the banIn their appeals, NRAI and FHRAI argued that collecting service charges was a practice followed by the hospitality industry for more than 80 years and should not be treated as an unfair trade practice.NRAI contended that restaurants which clearly disclose service charges on their menus and inform customers before they place orders should be allowed to collect them.The association argued that service charges are not merely additional earnings for restaurants but are distributed among employees, including waiters, kitchen staff and other workers. It said the system also ensures that employees who do not directly interact with customers receive a share of the collection.The restaurant associations questioned whether the issue should be governed by consumer protection laws or labour laws, particularly when charges are clearly disclosed to customers.They also referred to judicial decisions, labour settlements and wage-related arrangements recognising service charges, including the Supreme Court’s 1964 judgment in Management of Wenger & Co. v. Their Workmen.The CCPA issued guidelines on July 4, 2022, prohibiting hotels and restaurants from automatically adding service charges to food bills.The move followed consumer complaints that establishments were adding charges, generally ranging from 5% to 20%, without seeking customers’ consent.NRAI approached the Delhi HC on July 18, 2022, challenging the guidelines. FHRAI later filed a separate petition raising similar objections.

Share your thoughts in the comments